Hulu’s take on Russian empress Catherine the Great is occasionally true. But it’s usually worthy of its TV-MA rating.
Chip was doing just fine without faith.
Sure, he knows about God and Jesus and all that. He was raised in the Roman Catholic Church, after all. But, like many folks, he came to a point where religion just didn’t feel like it was all that relevant to his day-to-day life. Jesus doesn’t do the dishes for him. The Holy Spirit never points out a prime parking spot. I mean, he’s a movie critic, fer cryin’ out loud. How’s faith going to help him write a review of Black Panther? (Unless he goes to work for, say, Plugged In, I mean?)
His wife says, “I consider Chip Catholic like I consider Olive Garden Italian.”
But Chip’s perspective on religion changes when his life suffers a one-two blow. First, his best friend of 30 years unexpectedly dies. Second, wife Leslie announces that she’s pregnant. Like many folks, Chip finds newfound relevance in religion in the wake of these massive life-changes, and he feels the need to reconnect with God.
But Chip is kind of an all-or-nothing guy. It’s not enough to start going to church or just setting up some quiet time. He wants to live by the Good Book, as it were: “to the letter.”
Wow. To the letter. Leafed through the book of Leviticus lately?
Yes, we could tell fictional Chip that he doesn’t need to follow the Bible’s laws to the letter: Paul says in Romans 6:14 that Christians “are not under law but under grace,” which means that I can eat a bacon cheeseburger without overwhelming spiritual guilt. We’re made right with God by faith in Jesus, not by our own moral perfection, Paul adds in Ephesians 2:8-10.
And we wouldn’t be the only ones delivering that message to Chip. “You do realize it will be impossible to truly live by the Bible, right?” Father Gene, Chip’s new spiritual adviser, asks him at the outset. And Leslie simply asks, “Couldn’t you go to church one time before making this huge commitment?”
No, Chip says. Half measures won’t cut it—not when he’s trying to transform himself into a better husband, future father and all-around awesome human being. Seeing his commitment, Leslie—despite being a nonbeliever herself—offers what support she can.
But as Christians know, it’s pretty hard to live biblically even when we ignore the instructions to the Israelites about, say, wearing different kinds of fabrics: Temptations lurk all around us. Every situation seems to lure us with compromise. Every human, worldly instinct we have encourages us to lash out when we should be turning the other cheek. It’s not a question of if Chip will fall off the biblical wagon, but when and how often.
The question is—as it is for all of us—will he get back on?
If CBS has its druthers, Chip’ll be on that wagon for several seasons.
Let me confess: I was leery about watching Living Biblically. Dreading reviewing it, actually. Loosely based on A. J. Jacobs’ bestselling nonfiction book The Year of Living Biblically, I thought that the show would likely skewer religion and, by extension, mock those who believe and adhere to the Christian variety.
But when I talked with the show’s creator, Patrick Walsh, he said that wasn’t the show’s purpose at all.
“I think a big reason that CBS took the gamble on the show was just me saying, I do not wish to mock faith. I have a great deal of respect for faith. I was raised very strictly Catholic, and all of my friends were extremely religious,” he said. “The only time you ever hear about religion is Bill Maher saying terrible things about people of faith, or on the flip side, [explicitly religious entertainment] that is maybe a little exclusionary to people who are not of faith—shows that appeal only to people with that exact same viewpoint. So my goal was to kind of bridge that gap and to hopefully serve all these people looking for entertainment about their lives, [but] not finding it.”
Let’s be honest: Not everyone will find Living Biblically entertaining, regardless of Walsh’s intentions. The sitcom does not come to the table content-free: We hear a bit of bad language. We might be exposed to plot points involving behavior such as infidelity or lying. Most of the show’s deepest theological discussions take place in a bar.
And Living Biblically does poke fun at faith sometimes. If I’ve learned anything in my gig as a Plugged In reviewer, it’s that we Christians can take ourselves, our faith and our entertainment really, really seriously. Living Biblically, in its sometimes winking attitude toward religion and its sometimes casual relationship with orthodox theology, will rub some would-be viewers the wrong way.
Here’s a good litmus test to determine whether you (or someone you know) might respond that way: If you’re offended by the fact that Chip has a tiny Jesus figure on his keychain and calls it “Keysus,” this show’s probably not for you.
But all those caveats aside, there’s also a great deal to like about this show. In fact, in some significant ways it’s a refreshing and welcome addition to prime time.
Yes, faith can be funny, Living Biblically tells us. But it’s also a really positive force in Chip’s life. He turned to the Bible to make himself a better person. And you know what? It’s working. When was the last time you saw a network sitcom do that? Ever?
Morality matters here. Prayer matters. Faith matters. And it matters in the best of ways.
Then there’s the interplay between Chip and his secular friends and family. I find the relationship between him and his nonbelieving wife particularly touching. She can’t buy into Chip’s newfound biblical devotion (yet?), but she sees the changes that his spiritual journey is making in his life. And when her angry, atheist mom comes to visit, trying to play an unwelcome spiritual “gotcha” game with Chip, Leslie tells her to lay off. “This whole Bible thing, it’s really good for him,” she says.
“An aspect of this show was to present a lot of people with extremely different beliefs who are coming to a better understanding of each other,” Walsh told me. “They might not always love what the other one is saying. They might not change their whole lifestyle because of it, but at least they’re listening with respect.”
No, Living Biblically doesn’t get everything right. And when we try to live biblically ourselves, neither do we. But it’s trying. This show may not reflect our faith perfectly, but it does attempt to reflect the power and beauty that we see in it, and that we’d like others to see.
And again I ask: When was the last time a show did that?
Chip vows that he won’t lie anymore, no matter the circumstance or how much trouble it may cause.
When Leslie and Chip go on a double date with Vince and his new girlfriend, Chip hurts Vince’s feelings by telling him he doesn’t like her. As they leave the restaurant, Chip and Leslie run into one Leslie’s coworkers who is upset that Leslie lied to her to get out of their dinner plans, originally made for that same evening. And when a new and impressive writer is hired on at the paper, Chip’s brutal honesty about their work environment leaves the newbie questioning whether he should’ve come on at all.
Chip, his “God squad” and other friends all meet together at a bar to drink beer and other hard liquor. Someone eats marijuana-filled gummy bears.
The words “h—,” “p-ssed” and “b—s are each heard once. A couple kisses. A few women wear clothes that reveal cleavage. People lie often—sometimes at the expense of others—but often to illustrate how corruptive lying can be. There are multiple jokes made about sex, as well as crude references to the male anatomy. Also, people joke about being “pushed down the steps” and getting smashed in the head.
Chip and his “God squad,” made up of Father Gene and Rabbi Gil, tell Chip that his phone has become his “false idol.” Now Chip must figure out how to navigate the demands of everyday life without his smartphone.
When Chip smashes his phone after an “idol smashing” conversation with Rabbi Gil and Gene, he decides to use old-school counterparts (like a map and a compass) instead of buying a new phone. But this causes a problem later when he sleeps in and forgets his “love-a-versary.”
Chip’s phoneless existence also becomes a problem for his coworkers who assume he’s been murdered. They find a “blood” covered shirt in his desk (the blood is actually salsa), and investigate after having watched a show on “cereal and serial killers.”
We hear the words “d–n,” “d–mit” and “a–” once each. Twice we hear the words “h—,” “b–tard” and “stupid.” Chip tells a group of kids that they’re “going to hell.” Someone misuses God’s name and mentions taking a “tasteful, topless selfie.” People are referred to as “cracked-out morons.” A man confesses an affair he’s having. Characters drink beer, have “celebratory drinks” and discuss “pre-gaming” before a concert. We see Chip in his boxers twice (with a shirt on), and Leslie in bed with a camisole (revealing some cleavage). The two also kiss multiple times.
There’s conversation about everyone being a sinner and Abraham trying to kill his only son. A ticket saleswoman says “we don’t sell Wiggles tickets to single men.” Someone says “I hate my friends because of Instagram.” Chip jokes about bowing to Michael Keaton (and about a cousin’s fingers getting blown off by fireworks) and Leslie says Beyoncé is a “goddess” whom she worships, since she turned “a cheating husband into lemonade.”
After his best friend dies and he learns his wife is pregnant, Chip decides that his life needs a spiritual overhaul. But when he decides to follow the Bible and its precepts to the letter, he begins to realize what a tricky path it is that he’s chosen to walk.
He quickly discovers that the Bible has a provision against wearing two types of fabric (Leviticus 19:19), and he solemnly tells his wife that he won’t be able to touch her during her period (Leviticus 15:19-33). But Chip also learns that it’ll be much harder to mock an annoying coworker he’s consistently made fun of. “I’m not going to be able to participate in hating Gary anymore,” he sadly says. Nor can Chip turn a blind eye to Gary’s ongoing extramarital affair when he sees him and his mistress sharing dinner.
Chip realizes that he can’t treat Gary like he would’ve in biblical times (given that it would’ve required a stoning). But he does hit Gary with a rock in a restaurant. Later, Gary thanks Chip for his, um, rocky rebuke. “I told Tracy [his wife] everything,” Gary says. “I’ve been a bad person. We’re going to go to counseling.”
Beforehand, though, we hear Gary brag about the affair and ogle women. Someone references the time when “Brenda’s top fell off during the Christmas party.” There are references to circumcision, out-of-wedlock pregnancy and “super-gonorrhea.” Someone jokingly talks about how much she loves “my filthy, filthy sex rap.”
People drink wine and beer. Chip’s priest, Father Gene, and Gene’s best friend, a Rabbi named Gil, hang out in a bar. When Chip asks Gene about the church’s take on marijuana, Gene says, “We don’t love it.” Someone jokes that Gary lives in “devil country now, area code 666.” One of Chip’s coworkers apparently escaped a cult six months earlier. We hear references to gluttony. Chip lights a candle for his friend in a church.
Characters say “d–n” a couple of times, along with “h—,” “a–“, “b–ch” and “crap.” We hear a reference to defecation.
Paul Asay has been part of the Plugged In staff since 2007, watching and reviewing roughly 15 quintillion movies and television shows. He’s written for a number of other publications, too, including Time, The Washington Post and Christianity Today. The author of several books, Paul loves to find spirituality in unexpected places, including popular entertainment, and he loves all things superhero. His vices include James Bond films, Mountain Dew and terrible B-grade movies. He’s married, has two children and a neurotic dog, runs marathons on occasion and hopes to someday own his own tuxedo. Feel free to follow him on Twitter @AsayPaul.
Kristin Smith joined the Plugged In team in 2017. Formerly a Spanish and English teacher, Kristin loves reading literature and eating authentic Mexican tacos. She and her husband, Eddy, love raising their children Judah and Selah. Kristin also has a deep affection for coffee, music, her dog (Cali) and cat (Aslan).
Hulu’s take on Russian empress Catherine the Great is occasionally true. But it’s usually worthy of its TV-MA rating.
Adora’s pledge to fight for “the honor of Grayskull” may lose sight of other honorable qualities.
Snowpiercer is rated TV-MA for basically every reason you can imagine. In the end, it left me cold.
Apple TV+’s latest effort is a buzzy crime thriller about two layer parents defending their teen son in a murder case.