Crime
Young Sherlock
It may suffer from an identity crisis, but Young Sherlock is still much cleaner than other recent interpretations of the iconic detective.
Hollywood’s adoration for Six Feet Under follows a familiar pattern of praise that has elevated the status of Sex and the City and The Sopranos, two other envelope-pushing HBO series.
Leaving out the detective angle so popular in morgue shows from Quincy to CSI, American Beauty producer Alan Ball peers into the fictional goings-on of a mom-and-pop funeral parlor in Los Angeles. When Nathaniel Fisher, Sr. suddenly requires the services of his own business, sons David (Michael C. Hall) and Nate (Peter Krause) take it over. David is a dapper worker-bee who “just so happens” to have sex with other men. Nate’s a melancholy prodigal ensnared in a desperately unhealthy—straight—relationship. Timid and quaint, Mom (Frances Conroy) shocks even herself by obsessively pursuing a brusque florist. It’s also revealed she had been carrying on an affair before her husband’s death.
Those sexual preoccupations leave the teenage Claire (Lauren Ambrose) to raise herself. They also generate a cloud of despair darkened by a steady stream of drugs and alcohol. No one protests when Claire drinks beer, smokes pot and experiments with mushrooms. That’s probably because most of her adult role models have moved on to harder substances.
Routinely replacing chemicals as a mood modifier is sex. Gay sex. Group sex. Oral sex. Pornography. If this MA-rated TV series were a movie, its frank displays of simulated sexual acts—with explicit male and female nudity—would take it out of R territory and into NC-17.
Other staples include vulgar language and . . . corpses. As many as 50 f-words (often used as verbs) demolish every episode. And the f-word isn’t the most obscene expression uttered. Meanwhile, a morbid succession of dead bodies, some of them displayed nude, shroud even lighter moments.
Choice bits of wisdom drown in the formaldehyde. Claire slowly learns not to judge people without trying to get to know them first. Nate comes face to face with the awfulness of having encouraged old girlfriends to get abortions. But there aren’t enough Emmy awards in the world to justify sitting through an orgy hoping to witness a random object lesson.
Episodes Reviewed: May 5, 12, 19, July 14, 21, 28, 2002
(Editor’s Note: Plugged In is rarely able to watch every episode of a given series for review. As such, there’s always a chance that you might see a problem that we didn’t. If you notice content that you feel should be included in our review, send us an email at letters@pluggedin.com, or contact us via Facebook or Instagram, and be sure to let us know the episode number, title and season so that we can check it out.)
It may suffer from an identity crisis, but Young Sherlock is still much cleaner than other recent interpretations of the iconic detective.
The opening song asks how one might get to ‘Sesame Street,’ and we’ll help you decide whether or not you should go.
Before you dive into one piece of One Piece, you’ll want to consider the issues that sail along with it.
