Notice: All forms on this website are temporarily down for maintenance. You will not be able to complete a form to request information or a resource. We apologize for any inconvenience and will reactivate the forms as soon as possible.

Black Cake

Black Cake season 1

Credits

Cast

Network

Reviewer

Kristin Smith

TV Series Review

Eventually the truth will resurface. When it does, you must reckon with it.

Eleanor Bennett tried everything in her power to keep her past behind her. But then she died. And in death, that past finally decided to speak.

Eleanor lived a full life–something her son, Byron, and daughter, Mathilda, know well. But their knowledge of their mother’s “full life” only went back so far. While the two loved their mother, they know little of her past.

That is, until the two are reunited, after eight years apart, to review her will. And those secrets spill out.

It seems Eleanor was waiting for the perfect moment to tell her children the truth. To tell them about who she really was.

Eleanor grew up in the 1960s on a Caribbean island. Back then, her name was Covey. She was abandoned by her mother when she was just 11 and was raised by her protective but troubled father.

By the time she turned 17, Covey only felt free when she was swimming. She wanted more from life; to spend her days with her best friend, Bunny, and bask in the love of her secret boyfriend, Gibbs, and maybe even sneak away with him to London.

But life had other plans.

Covey’s father was a gambling man, and his poor decisions led him to sell his young daughter in marriage to a violent, powerful loan shark. Yet, on the night of their wedding, Covey’s husband fell to the ground, dead. Poisoned.

This was her only chance. Slip away quickly and never come back.

So she did. She fled to the only place she had ever felt free. The ocean. And the ocean carried her on a ship to London, to a new life.

This was the fresh start she had always desired. Or so she thought.

Eleanor spent the rest of her days burying her friendships, her father and Covey, the girl she used to know. But it seems her past would bleed into the present in ways she and her future family would never expect.

To Tell The Whole Truth, And Nothing But…

What is the truth? And how can you tell when you’re hearing it?  According to Hulu’s latest series, Black Cake, it’s complicated.

This TV-MA series, produced by Oprah Winfrey and based off of the novel of the same name by Charmaine Wilkerson, is steeped in mystery, drama and intricacies.

For starters, the main character here, Covey, receives her new name, Eleanor Bennett, through death. The show hints that young Covey is willing to do whatever it takes to establish a new life for herself. How far she’s willing to go will be doled out one episode at a time.

But it’s not just focused on the past. There are three concurrent stories being told. In the past, we learn about Covey and the new life she embarks upon. In the present, we learn about her children: Byron and Mathilda, their individual lives and how the news of their mother’s past leads them to uncover parts of their heritage and story they never knew existed.

We find themes of resilience, betrayal, hope, racism, assimilation, friendship and love. And it’s clear that this series will be both rich and complicated, wrapped in mystery, murder and life.

Which means that there is, and will be, plenty of content issues. Young and old alike use profanity (and it can be harsh) and drink alcohol. There’s reference to drug use and gambling. There’s murder, sex (although not graphic, at least based on the first episode) and some other other issues as well. 

There’s heart to this show, but that heart can be both filled with light and steeped in darkness–often at the same time.

Episode Reviews

Nov. 1, 2023 – S1, E1: “Covey”

In the present, Eleanor finds out she has a brain tumor and shortly thereafter passes away. Her children, Mathilda and Byron, are left with the truth about her past; In the past, Covey embraces her youth until her father, Lin, sells her into a marriage against her will.

A group of men burn down Lin’s shop. Later, Lin finds out it’s an act of racism as he’s an unwelcome Asian man living in a Caribbean community.

Covey tells her father that he is a “drunk” and an “unfit” parent. She believes her father hates her because she resembles her mother when, in reality, he hates himself and feels guilty that his wife left him due to his gambling and unwise choices.

Covey feels unloved and unvalued as her mother abandoned her and her father when Covey was only 11. This plays into some of her life choices and how she views herself.

An older man, a loan shark, makes a pass at Covey, threatening her life and that of her father, Lin. He and his brothers leer at her multiple times.

Lin essentially sells Covey into marriage with the loan shark in exchange for all of his debt to be paid off. Lin is told that Covey is fearless and that “a fearless girl without a mother or a husband to keep her in check is a dangerous thing.”

At the wedding, Covey tells her father that he is “dead” to her. Her new husband is poisoned and killed and Covey flees, jumping into the ocean and getting on a boat to London with hopes of starting a new life. Covey insinuates that she must kill her new roommate and steal her identity.

Lin is punched, beaten and threatened by two men after they assume that Covey is responsible for her husband’s death.

Covey and her boyfriend, Gibbs, make out. Soon after, Gibbs takes his shirt off and the two talk about having sex while kissing on the beach and, although the camera pans away, it’s insinuated that they do. Women wear one-piece, cleavage-baring bathing suits and men wear swim trunks.

While swimming during a hurricane, Covey nearly dies, and she believes it’s the sea’s way of punishing her for sneaking out with her boyfriend and lying to her father about her whereabouts.

A woman drinks wine and a man drinks hard liquor. The latter is often seen inebriated.

We hear the f-word used twice. God’s name is misused twice and Jesus’ name is misused once. A woman is called a “b–ch” and Covey’s father refers to his estranged wife with a racial slur.

The Plugged In Show logo
Elevate family time with our parent-friendly entertainment reviews! The Plugged In Podcast has in-depth conversations on the latest movies, video games, social media and more.
kristin-smith
Kristin Smith

Kristin Smith joined the Plugged In team in 2017. Formerly a Spanish and English teacher, Kristin loves reading literature and eating authentic Mexican tacos. She and her husband, Eddy, love raising their children Judah and Selah. Kristin also has a deep affection for coffee, music, her dog (Cali) and cat (Aslan).

Latest Reviews

Drama

Doctor Who

The good Doctor’s been flitting around time, space and the BBC since 1963. Now he’s also a fixture in the US, toting his curiously British brand of sci-fi in his highly mobile TARDIS. Just how safe is this contraption?

Drama

The Big Cigar

The Big Cigar’s protagonist, Huey P. Newton, founder of the Black Panthers, is suspicious of Hollywood. In that, Plugged In would agree.

Animation

Milo

Milo offers great messages about friendship and trying new things, and it’s free of most anything parents would find concerning.

Drama

Destination Heaven

People from all walks of life learn lessons from God Himself that will change their lives.