Skip Navigation

TV Reviews

 
MPAA Rating
Genre
Drama, Comedy
Cast
Blake Lively as Serena van der Woodsen; Leighton Meester as Blair Waldorf; Penn Badgley as Dan Humphrey; Chace Crawford as Nate Archibald; Taylor Momsen as Jenny Humphrey; Ed Westwick as Chuck Bass; Kelly Rutherford as Lily van der Woodsen; Jessica Szohr as Vanessa Abrams; Hilary Duff as Olivia Burke
Channel
CW
Reviewer
Adam R. Holz

Gossip Girl

What happens when you have a trust fund at 17 and millionaire parents whose self-absorption rivals any preening adolescent? Teens are tuning in to Gossip Girl to find out. In droves. Based on the racy young-adult novels by Cecily von Ziegesar, CW’s Gossip Girl chronicles the exploits of über-privileged Manhattan adolescents. Soapy, syrupy, silly and sappy—not to mention sexual—this hormone- and cash-fueled drama is narrated by an anonymous blogger known only as "Gossip Girl."

Episode Reviews

November 9, 2009

TV Parental Guidelines Rating: tv14

" They Shoot Humphreys, Don’t They? "

Two years ago when this CW teen soap let loose its first gregarious giggle, I asked, "Which of Gossip Girl’s wildly mixed messages are young viewers most likely to internalize—and emulate? Will they pay closer attention to Serena’s mature decisions to turn from destructive choices? Or will it be the parade of high schoolers drinking, gambling, smoking pot, flaunting lingerie, occasionally engaging in casual sex and living as if there were no rules?"

The answer has for some time now been emphatically answered. And the Nov. 9 episode merely adds insult to injury. In doing so, though, it generated as much pre-broadcast publicity as anything I’ve seen for some time. The reason? CW had promised it would include a ménage à trois.

Leaked information about a sexual threesome on the teen-oriented show began to surface weeks before the airdate. The only mystery was which characters would be involved.

But I’m not sure any of us expected Lizzie McGuire to lead the charge. Well, not Lizzie exactly. But Hilary Duff. Close enough.

Duff joined the cast of Gossip Girl this year, and she clearly seems more than willing to help push the show into increasingly risqué territory. Los Angeles Times television reviewer Enid Portuguez said of Duff’s involvement, "If this was her segue into more adult roles, she’s surely got an enthusiastic game face on."

The promised three-way involves Duff’s character, Olivia, her roommate, Vanessa, and their good buddy Dan. The catalyst for the tryst? A list of 15 crazy things every college student should do before graduating (and they’ve already completed the first 14).

By the time the credits roll, the camera has spied several passionate kisses among the threesome (including one between Olivia and Vanessa) and all three exhausted participants sacked out together—their romp concluded.

The fact that the onscreen proceedings don’t get more explicit than kissing hardly blunts the impact of the message: Having a threesome is just normal college behavior. In fact, you’d be missing out, it’s suggested, if you skipped this pinnacle of college debauchery.

In a case of unintentional irony, elsewhere in this episode high school girls at a posh debutante ball receive designated mentors to help them navigate the potential land mines and faux pas that could be their social undoing.

Now if only the many young women watching this show—it’s the No. 1 show among 12- to 34-year-old females in its time slot, according to CW press release—had a mentor to help them avoid the moral land mines onscreen.

September 19, 2007

TV Parental Guidelines Rating: tv14

The series opens with the return of Serena van der Woodsen, a captivating queen bee swept off to boarding school (at least that’s her story) the year before. Now she’s back, much to the consternation of her former BFF, the conniving Blair Waldorf. Orbiting these warring alpha girls is a constellation of beautiful, martini-sipping teens who are shuttled around in limos, puff on joints and often embody a Sex and the City-style relationship ethos.

Minutes into the premiere, for example, Blair drags boyfriend Nate to her bedroom to consummate their relationship. Frenzied kissing and garment removal halt when Blair mentions that Serena is back. Soon we learn that Nate can’t get Serena off his mind, thanks to a bodice-grasping flashback that reveals how the pair stumbled into a drunken sexual tryst the year before.

Arguably, even more poorly behaved are the teens’ filthy-rich parents, whose bad examples in relationships, sex and financial stewardship offer virtually nothing positive for their children to emulate. Nor is there an intact, healthy marriage anywhere to be seen. The only bright spot when it comes to parenting is Rufus, an aging and relatively poor rock star dad who engages with his teens and sacrifices for their needs.

Commenting on the Hollywood-caliber train wrecks mirrored by characters on her show, star Blake Lively told CosmoGIRL!, "When you don’t have someone to model yourself after, you’re going to make mistakes. There’s no one there to tell them what’s right or wrong or who is a positive example."

More